The BEST Apple Juice Substitutes (Plus Keto Option)
This post may contain affiliate links. Please see my disclosure policy for details.
When it comes to baking and cooking, finding the right substitution can be tricky. This is especially true when you find yourself missing apple juice for a recipe and need to find the best alternative juice. If that’s the case, don’t worry – we have all the tips and tricks you need! With our guidance, you can quickly find the best apple juice substitutes.
But before we dive into our options, let’s make sure we understand what apple juice tastes like. I know that might sound funny, but it helps us find the perfect replacement.
What Does Apple Juice Taste Like?
Apple juice has a fresh and tart flavor. Its sweetness is usually balanced with a slightly acidic taste that is distinctively characteristic of apples. Depending on the type of apple used to make the juice, it can have a range of subtle or complex flavors, such as hints of cinnamon, caramel, or honey.
Many people enjoy drinking cold apple juice and savoring its flavor. However, some prefer drinking warm apple juice because it brings out the full flavor of the fruit. Of course, apples come in a wide variety of types, and each can give the drink its own unique profile that slightly varies from others. But overall, these are some key characteristics to look for:
Key Characteristics Of Apple Juice
- Sweet (some varieties are tangy)
- Semi-translucent color
- Fruity
- Crispy and Refreshing
Substitutes For Apple Juice
All the apple juice alternatives below can be used at a ratio of 1 to 1. Meaning a cup of apple juice can be subbed with a cup of pear juice.
I do want to say if you do have fresh apples on hand and a juicer, you can technically make your own homemade apple juice. This is by far not an easy substitution, but it can be done. But if you lack those two things or time is of the essence, then continue reading!
Apple Cider
Apple cider will be the closest substitute when it comes to tasting like apple juice. It’s a type of fermented beverage made from the juice of apples. The production process typically involves pressing apples to extract the liquid and then fermenting it over several weeks or months. Depending on its ingredients, fermentation method, and duration, apple cider can vary in color, flavor, strength, and clarity.
Generally, apple cider is intensely flavored but typically very low in alcohol content. It is commonly served cold over ice or heated with cinnamon and sugar added for extra flavor. Fun fact…Apple cider has been produced since ancient times!
Pear Juice
If apple juice is nowhere to be found, then go for pear juice! It’s a refreshing and sweet beverage that can be enjoyed chilled or heated. Its flavor is distinct from other juices like apples because pears’ acidity and sugar content differ from those of apples. Pears are also higher in fiber than apples, making pear juice have a thicker, smoother texture. But it can lend a lot of similar flavors to an apple, especially when you are comparing it to other fruits.
Pear Cider
Pear cider is an alcoholic beverage made from fermented apple or pear juice. It is not as sweet as other ciders and has smaller bubbles due to a slower fermentation process. A unique characteristic of pear cider is its light color, which ranges from pale yellow to golden brown. Depending on the region and type of pear juice used, pear cider usually contains at least four percent alcohol by volume, though some brands contain up to eight percent alcohol. No need to worry about the alcohol if you are using it in cooking or baking!
White Grape Juice
White grape juice will be a much sweeter option, but it will work in a pinch to replace apple juice. White grape juice is made exclusively from green grapes. It is made by pressing the sweet and juicy flesh of the grapes, which are a variety of species in the genus Vitis, to extract the liquid.
White grape juice is commonly found in bottle form and has a distinctively sweet and mildly tart flavor. Most major grocery stores carry it. And the great thing about this juice is that it can also be used for baking and cooking. So, great swap for apple juice in recipes.
Apple Cider Vinegar (Keto – Low Carb)
If the recipe calls for a small amount of apple juice, like less than 1/4 of a cup. You could use apple cider vinegar. You could also dilute it with water for larger amounts of apple juice in the recipe. But I want to emphasize “could.” This depends on your recipe; you will need to add some sweetness, such as sugar, honey, or stevia.
This can also work for those on keto or a low-carb diet. Apple cider vinegar has no sugar in it, making it a great option. But you will have to dilute the mixture and, as mentioned earlier, add a sweetener. My go-to would be a monkfruit blend or a stevia blend.
Apple cider vinegar is a type of vinegar that is made through the process of fermenting apple juice. The finished product has a slightly cloudy appearance and should have sediment deposits at the bottom of the container, as it still contains all of its natural enzymes, minerals, and vitamins.
It has been used for centuries in food preparation and for its many health benefits, from aiding digestion and weight loss to treating skin ailments such as acne. Apple cider vinegar also makes an excellent choice for dressing salads or finishing off cooked dishes, as its mild acidity creates a delightful balance with other flavors.
Juices I Don’t Recommend As An Alternative to Apple Juice
The world wide web can pull up some off-the-wall suggestions for substitutes. Apple juice is included! Just because another fruit is a juice doesn’t mean it’s a good swap for apple juice. Here at The Substitute Foodie, I will always give it to you straight. Here are some juices and other ingredients I can’t recommend as a replacement for apple juice.
- Orange Juice
- Lime Juice
- Lemon Juice
- Grapefruit Juice
- Pineapple Juice
Citrus juices lend the same flavor as apple juice and can be extremely tart. Depending on your recipe, this could be a disaster. For example, making Stuffed Chicken with Apple Gravy and swapping the apple juice with lime juice isn’t going to work!
- Pineapple Juice
Pineapple may have the word apple in its name, but it doesn’t taste or work like apple juice. Even though pineapple has a lovely tropical flavor, it also has an enzyme called bromelain. This can affect certain recipes if the pineapple juice isn’t cooked. Trust me; I learned this hard way trying to make pineapple ice cream.
- Other Vinegar
Not sure why some suggest using vinegar like red wine vinegar, balsamic, white vinegar, and more. These are NOT good substitutes for apple juice. If you are going to go with vinegar, stick with apple cider vinegar.
My Final Thoughts On Substitutes For Apple Juice
Apple juice is a popular drink that can be enjoyed chilled or heated. It’s sweet and refreshing with a fruity flavor that comes from the apple. However, if you’re looking for a substitute, there are several options available.
Apple cider is the closest substitute in terms of taste, followed by pear juice. Pear cider is also an alcoholic beverage made from fermented pear juice. If you’re worried about alcohol (not cooking or baking), then white grape juice will be your best bet. But you can even find some ciders that are not hard. Just remember that white grape juice It’s sweeter than apple juice but has a similar flavor profile. No matter which one you choose, they all work in a 1-to-1 ratio. Happy Cooking!
